New York Bagels – 6 pk

(99 customer reviews)

$6.99 — or subscribe and save 7%

Set Up A Subscription Order

These bagels are made traditionally the old-fashioned New York-Style way! They have a wonderful slightly chewy texture and are great fresh or toasted. ORDER YOURS TODAY to get them baked fresh for you!!

Ingredients: Organic Unbleached Wheat Flour, Water, Organic Evaporated Cane Juice, Organic Coconut Oil, Organic Apple Cider Vinegar, Organic Flaxmeal, Sea Salt, Yeast

Weight 22 oz
Dimensions 8 × 4 × 3 in

99 reviews for New York Bagels – 6 pk

  1. Lori Simenauer
    02/09/2024
    Best bagels
    Garima Paul
    02/01/2024
    My favorite go-to bagels now. I won't be buying grocery store bagels anymore. Even the kids love them. I store them in the fridge but after lightly...More
    My favorite go-to bagels now. I won't be buying grocery store bagels anymore. Even the kids love them. I store them in the fridge but after lightly toasting, they are soft.
    Stephany Hoxholli
    01/08/2024
    I absolutely love these bagels, you can just taste that they’re so fresh and with better ingredients. This is my fourth time buying and I will keep bu...More
    I absolutely love these bagels, you can just taste that they’re so fresh and with better ingredients. This is my fourth time buying and I will keep buying more!!
    New York Bagels - 6 pk photo review
    Mary Riley
    01/06/2024
    So DELICIOUS!!! We are loyal customers! Every single item we have tasted is beyond amazing!
    Virginia Fiore
    01/03/2024
    Our favorite gift - this is the third year we have been gifted these bagels. We are so lucky!
    New York Bagels - 6 pk photo review
    New York Bagels - 6 pk photo review
    New York Bagels - 6 pk photo review
    +1
    Shelly Hansen
    12/03/2023
    Oh my gosh we get our subscription every 5 weeks. I believe this is the best bakery I ever found. Organic healthy products delivered with in days of b...More
    Oh my gosh we get our subscription every 5 weeks. I believe this is the best bakery I ever found. Organic healthy products delivered with in days of being baked! Amazing I liked being able to try your different baked goods with my subscription. We believe in your company and your family beliefs. Thank you
    Dominque Bennett
    11/12/2023
    These bagels are AMAZING, just like every other product I have tried. The flavor and texture are perfect (even after freezing for prolonged periods of...More
    These bagels are AMAZING, just like every other product I have tried. The flavor and texture are perfect (even after freezing for prolonged periods of time, and you can't beat the ingredients. I'll never buy another bagel!
    Jill
    03/27/2017
    DELICIOUS
    Very delicious!!!!! Toast up Great!!!!!!
    Linda
    04/07/2017
    Love These
    My kids and I absolutely LOVE these bagels!!!!!!!!!
    James Montgomery
    06/01/2017
    Um-um Good!! I don't eat a lot of bagels because they are usually tough and dry, but these bagels here are awesome! Very tasty and not dry at all. Tru...More
    Um-um Good!!
    I don't eat a lot of bagels because they are usually tough and dry, but these bagels here are awesome! Very tasty and not dry at all. Truly a blessing to eat!!!
    Carl
    07/20/2017
    Marvelous
    These bagels are not like the other bagels that I purchase at the grocery store. They are very tasty and blessed.
    Lindsay
    12/23/2017
    Clean, high quality flavor I can no longer eat mass-produced store-bought bagels. These blessed bagels are so delicious, and they present with a beaut...More
    Clean, high quality flavor
    I can no longer eat mass-produced store-bought bagels. These blessed bagels are so delicious, and they present with a beautiful texture, and give a delectable crisp when toasted... and the flavor is so clean and fresh!! I've been eating bagels all my life and these are one of the most fabulous. Thank you!
    Ambrogina A.
    02/28/2019
    Both Sister Margaret and I love your Products. So far we have ordered bread. Oatmeal cookies and bagels....all so good! We are so happy we found out ...More
    Both Sister Margaret and I love your
    Products. So far we have ordered bread. Oatmeal cookies and bagels....all so good!
    We are so happy we found out about you and your bakery. Thank you!
    God bless you !
    Dottie D.
    04/02/2019
    Love love these! Perfect bagels!
    C S.
    04/24/2019
    Best bagels I’ve had in a very long time
    Barbara B.
    04/24/2019
    I took the bagels to our traditional family brunch for Easter and everyone loved them....
    Christine V.
    04/30/2019
    Love these! More flavors please. Would love to see sourdough bagels--used to get them in NY!
    Lynn S.
    05/27/2019
    Kids love them
    Heather H.
    09/06/2019
    Love them! Delicious!!
    Dored S.
    10/22/2019
    The best out there!
    Annie J.
    10/25/2019
    Everything we've ordered is delicious! We are so glad to have found your healthy bread bakery! We're looking forward to trying more items!
    Roberta L.
    10/27/2019
    My husband enjoys the bagels with Almond Butter for breakfast!
    Kim G.
    11/01/2019
    Yum! Toasted, buttered and drizzle with honey and a little bit of cinnamon, these tastes like a warm, fresh donut!!
    Mark S.
    12/30/2019
    Great product. Delicious. Will continuing buying this product. Keep up the good work.
    Stephanie H.
    01/12/2020
    Great bagels, New York style. Cream cheese and butter all the way!
    Jeannie M.
    03/23/2020
    nicely toasted
    Fern S.
    03/31/2020
    We especially love the bagels!
    Susan M.
    04/02/2020
    Sorry Panera...these bagels from Organic Bread of Heaven are truly the best I’ve ever had. The cost of these bagels are even less than Panera’s.
    Kathleen D.
    04/06/2020
    Love the texture of these bagels! I just eat them plain but would be delicious with your favorite spread.
    Charles K.
    04/09/2020
    These were the first bagels I have ever had that behaved like I have always heard bagels were supposed to. Tough outside and soft center. Most other...More
    These were the first bagels I have ever had that behaved like I have always heard bagels were supposed to. Tough outside and soft center. Most others are hard outside and tough center. I really enjoyed them.
    Donna L.
    04/14/2020
    Just like a good bagel should be with wonderful flavor. I like mine best when toasted.
    terrence l.
    04/26/2020
    very good toasted
    lydia f.
    05/09/2020
    Love these bagels with cram cheese and lox. Perfection!
    Juli B.
    05/10/2020
    So fluffy and tasty
    Shelley L.
    05/11/2020
    Delish!
    Gloria E.
    05/12/2020
    For breakfast I toast these, then, drizzle with early pressed extra virgin organic olive oil and organic raw honey
    Yvonne Suzanne M.
    05/29/2020
    New York Bagels how can anyone not love these with a thick layer of cream cheese and lightly toasted in the toaster with a great cup of coffee while y...More
    New York Bagels how can anyone not love these with a thick layer of cream cheese and lightly toasted in the toaster with a great cup of coffee while you sit out on your porch. These are so delicious and if you want you can add a little bit of jam on top of the cream cheese. Love this product...Yvonne Suzanne Miller or (gg) which is great gramma
    Heather B.
    06/09/2020
    Awesome bagels!!
    Marguerite D.
    07/01/2020
    These bagels were delicious. My only complaint would be that I had to slice them. If they were split it would have been easier.
    Richard G.
    10/20/2020
    They're great. A good bagel has to have the right texture. These do. Very good.
    Patricia T.
    11/13/2020
    We live in Eastern Oregon and our order took a week to get here. It was still fresh! We are thrilled to have found a source of organic bread. We or...More
    We live in Eastern Oregon and our order took a week to get here. It was still fresh! We are thrilled to have found a source of organic bread. We ordered several kinds of sourdough bread and it is hard to pick a favorite. Will be ordering again soon. Thank you for excellent breads.
    Christina V.
    11/14/2020
    Our 10 year old daughter’s food allergies to milk, eggs, peanuts, tree nuts, and soy prevent us from purchasing store-bought bagels. Most have soy or...More
    Our 10 year old daughter’s food allergies to milk, eggs, peanuts, tree nuts, and soy prevent us from purchasing store-bought bagels. Most have soy or are at risk die cross contamination with her other allergens. These are a game changer. I purchased 18 bagels and they are almost completely gone in a little over a week. She is obsessed! I have already placed a second order.
    Agnes V.
    11/29/2020
    Love them.
    Jama P.
    12/06/2020
    Great as always!
    Linda Cuccia L.
    12/20/2020
    A staple in my house and delicious toasted with butter and homemade preserves and an omelette. Just pop them in the toaster and a slab of organic butt...More
    A staple in my house and delicious toasted with butter and homemade preserves and an omelette. Just pop them in the toaster and a slab of organic butter preserves and you're set. Wow I've purchased these many times before and I will continue to buy them. Thanks for a wonderful product.
    Carrie
    01/09/2021
    My husband and 10 year old daughter love these. I'm sure I would too if I ever got a chance to taste one, they keep eating them before I get a chance ...More
    My husband and 10 year old daughter love these. I'm sure I would too if I ever got a chance to taste one, they keep eating them before I get a chance to try one :)
    Karen L.
    01/31/2021
    Amazing bagels!
    Ausrine K.
    02/07/2021
    Perfect bagel
    Tricia G.
    03/18/2021
    The best!
    Connie H.
    03/19/2021
    Absolutely the best bagels we’ve ever had!!
    Tara P.
    03/27/2021
    Delicious bagels!
    Alan S.
    04/21/2021
    I have been buying these bagels in quantity for a while - they are my favorites. They are not expensive, not too big and are dense, unlike the "air b...More
    I have been buying these bagels in quantity for a while - they are my favorites. They are not expensive, not too big and are dense, unlike the "air bread" bagels at the grocery store, making for chewy goodness.
    Betty G.
    04/23/2021
    Just so happy to find organic bagels and bread!!! Thank you and please keep up the good work 🙏
    Carolyn Y.
    05/16/2021
    Tasty.
    Charlotte W.
    05/18/2021
    I seriously think these are the best bagels I’ve ever had. Yum!!
    CHANDERKANT S.
    08/17/2021
    kids love it
    Deanne J.
    08/18/2021
    I pick the box up from the porch at about 5am I opened it and it smelled so good. Then later that day we had a bagel yummy very good. Thank you
    Shannon S.
    11/02/2021
    We love everything we’ve ever ordered! Thank you for also shopping to the West Coast! It is such a treat to have your delicious products here. You are...More
    We love everything we’ve ever ordered! Thank you for also shopping to the West Coast! It is such a treat to have your delicious products here. You are our go-to brand!!!
    Kristen J.
    12/31/2021
    Bought these to have while family was staying with us. Became instant favorite breakfast item. Luckily I planned ahead and got extra or we would hav...More
    Bought these to have while family was staying with us. Became instant favorite breakfast item. Luckily I planned ahead and got extra or we would have run out of them.
    Virginia F.
    01/09/2022
    I ordered the bagels for my sister. When I asked her what her review would be, she sent me this: The bagels were delicious. They had a nice texture; t...More
    I ordered the bagels for my sister. When I asked her what her review would be, she sent me this: The bagels were delicious. They had a nice texture; the inside had a good “mouth feel”. I was skeptical about putting them in the fridge, but it didn’t change them. They stayed tender and flavorful.
    Lisa G.
    01/19/2022
    No better bagel! Our favorite!
    David H.
    03/06/2022
    My son has anaphylaxis to milk so when we found your bakery it was a God send. We have been getting these bagels for a little while now and the kids a...More
    My son has anaphylaxis to milk so when we found your bakery it was a God send. We have been getting these bagels for a little while now and the kids absolutely LOVE them (as do I)! In fact, we lost our home, and possessions, to the Marshall fire in Colorado on Dec 30th of this last year. As soon as we got temporary housing the first thing my kids wanted was Bread of Heaven bagels! You guys have turned into a comfort food for us :) Thanks much!
    Debra P.
    04/04/2022
    Delicious
    Lindsay B.
    05/04/2022
    Love these bagels! I feel good about giving these to my family knowing the ingredients are awesome!
    Giana C.
    05/17/2022
    Initially, I thought the bagel should be a bit larger, but it was just the right size. Delicious too. I will definitely order again.
    Marilyn G.
    05/22/2022
    Have always loved your bagels. I like them toasted with cream cheese. Also, the cinnamon bread is out of this world!! For Mother’s Day I sent my daugh...More
    Have always loved your bagels. I like them toasted with cream cheese. Also, the cinnamon bread is out of this world!! For Mother’s Day I sent my daughter a basket of goodies and they all enjoyed the variety of items in it. Your little personal notes are such a wonderful touch! Thank you for making delicious & healthy breads & other baked goods. Such a nice treat! Thanks!!
    Shannon S.
    06/15/2022
    We make so many things with these bagels. Bagel pizzas, bagel sandwiches...you name it! The only bagels that also are free of sesame seeds. Wahooo
    Richard H.
    07/11/2022
    Every product we have received has been excellent but the NY Bagels are our very favorite!
    Andrea D.
    08/17/2022
    These are the best bagels ever!!!
    ELYSE L.
    09/30/2022
    Love them!
    heidi f.
    10/13/2022
    My daughter never likes the bread without all the preservatives - I finally found a company that has awesome integrity and she loves everything - she ...More
    My daughter never likes the bread without all the preservatives - I finally found a company that has awesome integrity and she loves everything - she says are you sure this is healthy its so soft and delicious!
    Carlee A.
    12/24/2022
    Great flavor and texture! Will buy again! Love everything you make that I’ve tried so far!
    Toby S.
    01/12/2023
    WOW DELICIOUS!!!!!!!!! we all loved these
    Vicki C.
    02/05/2023
    So delicious, have that great NYC bagel combo of crunchy and chewy and good tasting.
    Shannon N.
    03/01/2023
    Disappeared way too fast! Made me feel good to see them go knowing that we were not compromising on nourishment for the kids.
    Anna K.
    03/07/2023
    AMAZING bagels! My fussy kids says these are the best they've ever tasted!
    Stella R.
    03/14/2023
    These were wonderful.
    Christine M.
    04/30/2023
    You have a forever customer!
    Celby G.
    05/01/2023
    We love this company and my daughter who is allergic to sesame and nuts and we had can't find ANY think like these baked goods that are safe for her.....More
    We love this company and my daughter who is allergic to sesame and nuts and we had can't find ANY think like these baked goods that are safe for her....gets SO happy when we purchase from you. Thank you for giving her the opportunity to love and enjoy baked goods that are safe for her!
    Lynn H.
    05/16/2023
    Delicious
    Elizabeth F.
    05/17/2023
    Our family has been loving this purchase!
    Marcella H.
    05/27/2023
    These are definitely my favorite bagels
    RACHEL C.
    05/30/2023
    I would personally love to tell you how wonderful these were but my children didn't share them with me, they kept taking them with cream cheese or but...More
    I would personally love to tell you how wonderful these were but my children didn't share them with me, they kept taking them with cream cheese or butter for after school snacks.
    Karen B.
    06/06/2023
    I live in New York and the bagels do not disappoint. I love them.
    Anshu U.
    06/15/2023
    Delicious! Good ingredients. Family loved them. Thank you!
    Francie J.
    07/10/2023
    LOVE these bengals for my daughter with multiple food allergies!
    Lisa Z.
    08/05/2023
    Best organic New York bagels from everything toasted, egg sandwiches and filled with delicious PB & J, egg or chicken salad !!!
    New York Bagels - 6 pk photo review
    Helen M.
    04/08/2019
    Nice and chewy and great flavor.
    New York Bagels - 6 pk photo review
    Stacey Y.
    07/17/2019
    We all love these bagels and they freeze really well too! I appreciate the clean ingredients.
    New York Bagels - 6 pk photo review
    Karen H.
    11/20/2019
    These bagels are delicious AND I feel good about feeding them to my kids...especially when slathered with vegan-blueberry cream cheese.
    New York Bagels - 6 pk photo review
    Hayley P.
    04/25/2020
    A family FAVORITE!
    New York Bagels - 6 pk photo review
    Stephenie D.
    05/01/2020
    Look at this beautiful specimen, and it's yummy too! Every thing we have ordered has been delicious and fresh, even after it was shipped to Southern C...More
    Look at this beautiful specimen, and it's yummy too! Every thing we have ordered has been delicious and fresh, even after it was shipped to Southern California.
    New York Bagels - 6 pk photo review
    Ilana G.
    07/29/2020
    The absolute best bagels EVER! We cannot be a week without them! My whole family loves them- they are amazing plain- or topped savory or sweet! The be...More
    The absolute best bagels EVER! We cannot be a week without them! My whole family loves them- they are amazing plain- or topped savory or sweet! The best!❤️
    New York Bagels - 6 pk photo review
    Laura G.
    04/27/2021
    We have loved everything we have tried from you all. Thank you for providing such great products with awesome ingredients!
    New York Bagels - 6 pk photo review
    Eva G.
    08/13/2021
    The bagels are very delicious are usually toast my bagels and either put cream cheese or some butter on it it’s very yummy.
    New York Bagels - 6 pk photo review
    Tara W.
    03/11/2022
    My kids love these bagels!
    New York Bagels - 6 pk photo review
    Ashley C.
    10/04/2022
    Seriously I love for these bagels in the morning!!! Never buying store bought bagels ever again!!
    New York Bagels - 6 pk photo review
    Mary R.
    06/06/2023
    We LOVE these bagels! Perfectly delicious, organic & fresh! We are so happy we found you!
    New York Bagels - 6 pk photo review
    Jamie D.
    07/10/2023
    We absolutely love these bagels! My fiancé never knew organic could taste so good! He loves everything we order--which is too much to list--but I wi...More
    We absolutely love these bagels! My fiancé never knew organic could taste so good! He loves everything we order--which is too much to list--but I will say these bagels along with the chocolate chip muffins, date honey muffins, and white bread for french toast are his favorites!

Only logged in customers who have purchased this product may leave a review.

Related products

Quick View

All Products

Banana Muffins (Sourdough)

$1.99 – $150.00 — or subscribe and save 7%
Quick View

All Products

100% Sprouted Sourdough Burger Buns – 8 pk

$7.99 — or subscribe and save 7%
Quick View

All Products

9 Inch Heart Cake – Chocolate – Date Syrup (Sourdough)

$19.99 — or subscribe and save 7%
Quick View

All Products

9 Inch Heart Cake – Apple

$19.99 — or subscribe and save 7%
Quick View

All Products

Apple Pie Swirl Challah

$8.99 — or subscribe and save 7%
Quick View

All Products

9 Inch Heart Date Honey Cake (Sourdough)

$19.99 — or subscribe and save 7%
Quick View

All Products

100% Sprouted Sourdough

$7.99 — or subscribe and save 7%
Placeholder
Quick View

All Products

2 Day Express Upgrade LG ORDER

$28.99 — or subscribe and save 7%
Close